2018-2019 Crossroads League Coach of the Year
Ryan Cottingham, Spring Arbor

2018-2019 Crossroads League Player of the Year
Kyle Mangas, Indiana Wesleyan

2018-2019 Crossroads League Defensive Player of the Year
Joel Okafor, Indiana Wesleyan

2018-2019 Crossroads League Freshman of the Year
Caleb Middlesworth, Huntington

2018-2019 First-Team All-Crossroads League
Kyle Mangas, Indiana Wesleyan
Paul Marandet, Spring Arbor
Trevion Crews, Bethel
Jevon Knox, Mount Vernon Nazarene
Wes Stowers, Marian
Evan Maxwell, Indiana Wesleyan

2018-2019 Second-Team All-Crossroads League
Reginald Kissoonlal, Marian
Brandon Durnell, Spring Arbor
Brett Vipperman, Mount Vernon Nazarene
Logan Godfrey, Grace
Paul Forman, Bethel
TJ Henderson, Marian

2018-2019 Third-Team All-Crossroads League
Demarkus Stuckey, Goshen
Ryan Robinson, Taylor
Connor Lautzenheiser, Saint Francis
Joel Okafor, Indiana Wesleyan
Caleb Middlesworth, Huntington

2018-2019 Honorable Mention All-Crossroads League
Jeff Beckman, Spring Arbor
Zac Owens, Huntington
Konner Platt, Huntington
Haden Deaton, Grace

2018-2019 Crossroads League All-Defensive Team
Joel Okafor, Indiana Wesleyan
Reginald Kissoonlal, Marian
Jeremiah Roberts, Mount Vernon Nazarene
Paul Marandet, Spring Arbor
Trevion Crews, Bethel

2018-2019 Crossroads League All-Freshmen Team
Caleb Middlesworth, Huntington
Jeffrey Reynolds, Saint Francis
CJ Penha, Taylor
Seth Maxwell, Indiana Wesleyan
Jared DeHart, Bethel